Down vs. Synthetic: The Real Trade-offs
Down insulation compresses smaller, weighs less, and lasts longer than synthetic when cared for properly. A quality 800-fill down bag will outlast a synthetic bag by years. The downside: wet down loses nearly all its insulating value and takes forever to dry.
Synthetic insulation retains warmth when wet, dries faster, and costs significantly less. It's heavier and bulkier than down at equivalent warmth ratings, and it degrades faster with use. For wet climates, shoulder seasons, or budget-conscious buyers, synthetic is the practical choice.
Understanding Fill Power
Fill power measures how much space one ounce of down occupies. 600-fill is entry-level; 800-fill is the sweet spot for backpacking; 900+ fill is premium ultralight territory. Higher fill power means you need less down to achieve the same warmth, resulting in a lighter, more compressible bag.
Don't get fooled by fill weight alone — a bag with 18 oz of 600-fill down is not the same as 18 oz of 850-fill down. The higher fill power bag will be warmer, lighter, and smaller.
Mummy vs. Semi-Rectangular
Mummy bags are tapered from shoulders to feet, minimizing dead air space your body has to heat. They're warmer and lighter for a given temperature rating. Semi-rectangular bags offer more room to move but are heavier and less thermally efficient.
For backpacking, mummy is almost always the right call. If you're a restless sleeper who hates feeling constricted, look for mummy bags with a wider cut — brands like Western Mountaineering and Feathered Friends offer roomier mummy options.