Canister Stoves: The Practical Choice
Canister stoves screw onto isobutane-propane fuel canisters and ignite instantly. They're reliable, easy to use, and available everywhere outdoor gear is sold. Boil times are fast (3–4 minutes for a liter), and they simmer reasonably well for actual cooking.
The downsides: fuel canisters are expensive, can't be refilled, and performance drops significantly below 20°F. You also can't tell how much fuel is left without a scale. For most 3-season backpacking, these are minor inconveniences. For winter camping, they're real problems.
Alcohol Stoves: Ultralight with Trade-offs
Alcohol stoves (like the classic Trangia or DIY cat food can stoves) weigh almost nothing and use denatured alcohol available at hardware stores. A complete alcohol stove setup can weigh under 2 oz. The trade-offs are significant: slow boil times (6–8 minutes), poor performance in cold and wind, no simmer control, and fuel that's hard to find in remote areas.
Alcohol stoves make sense for ultralight thru-hikers in warm conditions who primarily boil water for freeze-dried meals. For anyone who wants to actually cook, they're frustrating.
Integrated Systems: Fast but Specialized
Integrated systems like the Jetboil Flash and MSR Reactor combine a burner and pot into a single unit with a heat exchanger that dramatically improves fuel efficiency and boil times. The Jetboil Flash boils a liter in 100 seconds — nothing else comes close.
The limitation: they're designed for boiling, not cooking. The tall, narrow pot shape makes sautéing and simmering awkward. If your camp cooking is 'boil water, add to freeze-dried pouch,' an integrated system is ideal. If you want to cook real food, get a canister stove and a wide pot.